A clear lake below a waterfall

Hydropower & Fisheries: Oxygen for Releases & Cold-Water Fish

Oxygen for water released through a dam and for the cold-water fish above and below it: why releases run low in oxygen, how fish kills start, and two ways a cone adds oxygen.

01The Problem

Releases from the Bottom Carry Its Low Oxygen Downstream

Low oxygen below a dam starts at the bottom of the reservoir, where anoxic water also forms hydrogen sulfide. At Camanche Reservoir in California, hypolimnetic oxygenation raised the bottom water from under 1 mg/L to about 5 mg/L. Summer hydropower returned, and the hatchery below the dam has had no fish kill in 24 years.

Why It Happens

In summer the water near a low intake is the hypolimnion: cold, cut off from the air and short of oxygen. A dam that draws from it releases water with little dissolved oxygen, and it can carry hydrogen sulfide, ammonia and metals from the sediment. Salmon in the Mokelumne River below Camanche Reservoir need at least 7 mg/L.

Before oxygenation, low oxygen in the releases had kept Camanche's hydropower plant idle from August to November. The flow bypassed the turbines through a valve that sprays the release in a huge semicircular shower and aerates it. The few seconds of exposure could not remove enough hydrogen sulfide, which needs at least 6 hours, and did nothing for ammonia, metals or turbidity.

Source: Horne and Faisst 2022 (opens in a new tab)

The Cold Layer Fish Need Runs Out of Oxygen

Trout, salmon and kokanee need the cold water in summer. In a stratified reservoir, that is the layer that loses its oxygen.

Why It Happens

Salmonid guidelines prefer 5 to 7 mg/L of dissolved oxygen and avoid water under 2 mg/L. Before oxygenation at Camanche Reservoir, the lower hypolimnion held 1.4 to 2.2 mg/L, and sonar found no large fish there. They were squeezed into the warm water above.

Worse, anoxic bottom water makes hydrogen sulfide, which kills fast. The hatchery below Camanche Dam drew its water from the bottom layer. In the autumns of 1987 and 1989, about 300,000 young hatchery fish died, most likely from hydrogen sulfide.

Sources: Horne and Faisst 2022 (opens in a new tab); Horne 2019

02How It Works

Two Ways a Speece Cone® Adds Oxygen at a Dam, Without Mixing

Oxygenate the reservoir before the water reaches the intake, or oxygenate the release at the dam. Neither warms the cold layer.

The System in Detail

Any method that destratifies the reservoir warms the water a cold-water fishery depends on. At Camanche, mixing would have warmed summer and fall releases, against agreements for cool attraction flows for migrating salmon, and destroyed the two-story fishery: trophy bass in the warm upper water, trout and kokanee in the cool water below. Oxygenating the bottom kept both. It warms the bottom a little: 16.8 °C was projected at overturn, against 14.8 °C before.

Oxygen in the reservoir treats more than oxygen: at Camanche, soluble iron in the tailwater fell from 7,800 to 200 µg/L. Oxygen at the dam works where there is head: the Logan Martin cone took 21 cubic feet per second from the pool and used the dam's own head to pressurize the cone, and tests showed 95% absorption at flows of 22 to 25 cubic feet per second.

Breathing life into lakes (0:44). Why a lake's deep water runs out of oxygen, and how oxygen along the lakebed restores it without mixing the lake. Watch it on the films page

The Full Table

Two published cases of oxygen for hydropower releases

Two published cases of oxygen for hydropower releases

MeasureCamanche Reservoir, CALogan Martin Dam, AL
Where the oxygen goesHorne et al. 2019ECO₂, Logan Martin case study
Into the bottom layer of the reservoir, upstream of the intake
Into water taken from the pool above the dam, discharged below it
How the cone is pressurizedHorne et al. 2019ECO₂, Logan Martin case study
Placed on the bottom near the dam, which doubled oxygen solubility
By the head between the pool and the tailwater
Oxygen leaving the coneHorne et al. 2019ECO₂, Logan Martin case study
80 mg/L, diluted to about 8 mg/L by the manifold jets
About 50 mg/L
Measured resultHorne and Faisst 2022 (opens in a new tab)ECO₂, Logan Martin case study
Bottom water from under 1 mg/L to about 5 mg/L; summer hydropower restored
Over 90% oxygen absorption at design flow; 94% of saturation in about 30 seconds

03The Proof

With Oxygen at the Bottom, the Fish Move In

Dissolved oxygen in Camanche's bottom layer rose from under 1 mg/L to about 5 mg/L, and the cold layer became habitat again.

Every Result in One Table

Where the large fish were in Camanche Reservoir: share of sonar echoes by layer, before and after oxygenation began

Where the large fish were in Camanche Reservoir: share of sonar echoes by layer, before and after oxygenation began

LayerBeforeAfter
Warm surface layer (0 to 7 m)Horne and Faisst 2022 (opens in a new tab)
69.1%
19.1%
Thermocline (8 to 12 m)Horne and Faisst 2022 (opens in a new tab)
23.6%
8.2%
Upper hypolimnion (13 to 18 m)Horne and Faisst 2022 (opens in a new tab)
7.3%
22.7%
Lower hypolimnion (19 to 31 m)Horne and Faisst 2022 (opens in a new tab)
0%
50%

The same total number of echoes in both surveys. The authors found the change statistically significant.

  • 3,548 to 7,660a year

    Average Chinook salmon returns rose from 3,548 a year before oxygenation to 7,660 a year after it, and reached a record 19,867 in 2018.

    Source: Horne 2019

  • $6.5 milliona year

    The extra Chinook add $6.5 million a year to California's recreation, at the State Economist's $1,172 per adult fish.

How It Compares with Other Methods

Turbine venting, aerating weirs and valves that spray the release add air as the water leaves, but cannot clear hydrogen sulfide, which needs at least 6 hours. Destratification raises summer bottom-water temperatures, which harms cold-water fish in the reservoir and downstream. A rising bubble plume entrains warmer water and settles at mid-depth; a bubble-free plume stays dense and cool and hugs the bottom, where hydrogen sulfide forms. A downflow contact oxygenator works in the reservoir or at the dam, and dissolves the oxygen before the water leaves the cone.

Sources: Horne and Faisst 2022 (opens in a new tab); Beutel 2002; Horne et al. 2019; Horne, triple threat slides; ECO₂, oxygen supplementation strategy

04For Engineers

Read the Papers

Questions Lake Managers Ask

What dissolved oxygen do cold-water fish and hydropower releases need?

Salmonid guidelines cited by Horne and Faisst prefer 5 to 7 mg/L and avoid water under 2 mg/L. A release's limit depends on the river and the license: below Camanche Reservoir, salmon in the Mokelumne River need at least 7 mg/L, and low oxygen in the releases had kept the hydropower plant idle from August to November.

Why does aerating the hatchery water not stop the kill?

Hydrogen sulfide clears too slowly. At the Camanche hatchery, aeration raised dissolved oxygen to 8.6 to 9.2 mg/L, but tests showed hydrogen sulfide needed 6 to 12 hours of aeration to clear, and the water reached the fish in under 5 minutes.

Can a cone use the dam's own head?

Yes. At Logan Martin Dam, the cone at the base of the dam took 21 cubic feet per second from the pool and was pressurized by the head between the pool and the tailwater. The discharge carried about 50 mg/L, with over 90% oxygen absorption at design flow.

How quickly do fish respond?

Within weeks in the reservoir. About two months after oxygenation began at Camanche, sonar found half of the large fish in the deepest layer, which had held none the June before. Higher adult salmon returns followed about 3 years later.

Can a reservoir keep both a warm-water and a cold-water fishery?

Yes, if it stays stratified. Camanche kept its two-story fishery, with bass in the warm upper water and trout and kokanee in the cool water below, by oxygenating the bottom instead of mixing the reservoir.

Does oxygenation pay for its own power at a dam?

At Camanche it does. The hydropower plant, back in summer service, generates enough electricity to fully offset the cost of running the cone's water pump.

05The Next Step

Send Us Your Release & Fishery Numbers

The release flow, the dissolved oxygen you must meet, and your temperature and dissolved oxygen profiles are enough for a first look at the oxygen demand and the system. ECO₂'s engineers check the data for a technical fit, then send a system design with its estimated capital and annual operating costs, and can visit your site to confirm the data.

Lake Hodges, a reservoir among dry hills near San Diego, California

Lake Hodges, San Diego, California. 10,000 lbs/day. 2019.