Hypolimnetic Oxygenation 3: An Engineered Switch from Eutrophic to a Meso-/Oligotrophic State in a California Reservoir

How keeping Camanche Reservoir's sediments oxygenated with a Speece Cone® cut the phosphate and ammonium they released and, over the years that followed, its chlorophyll a.

Details

Publisher
Lake and Reservoir Management
Published
September 2019

Summary

Alex J. Horne and Marc Beutel's 2019 paper shows that a Speece Cone hypolimnetic oxygenation system (HOS), used with no other management, moved EBMUD's Camanche Reservoir in California from eutrophic to a meso-/oligotrophic state. Over the following 11 years, average growth-season chlorophyll a fell 79% and average Secchi depth rose tenfold.

Key Figures

Questions

What happened to phosphate and ammonium in the bottom water?

October bottom-water phosphate fell 84%, from 95 to 15 µg P/L, in the first years of oxygenation, and October ammonium from an average of 706 to 28 µg N/L. Large drops in phosphate, TP and ammonium appeared within 4 weeks of start-up. (PDF page 7) (opens in a new tab)

Why did nitrate not rise when the ammonium was oxidized?

October bottom nitrate rose only from 40 to 65 µg N/L. The authors think the nitrogen was most likely lost through coupled nitrification and denitrification in unevenly oxygenated sediments; anammox is possible but slow at the 13 °C sediment temperature. (PDF page 14) (opens in a new tab)

Was the oxygenation system the only treatment used at Camanche Reservoir?

Yes. The authors describe it as the first successful long-term use of a large HOS on its own; at Newman Lake, Washington, the Speece Cone worked alongside alum treatment and watershed improvements. (PDF page 12) (opens in a new tab)

What happens to water quality when the HOS is not run?

In 1995, when the HOS ran for only 1 week in late October, and during a 2001 electrical failure, surface TP and bottom phosphate spiked and bottom ammonium rose to 200 µg/L. Both returned to low levels once oxygenation resumed. (PDF page 9) (opens in a new tab)

Did zooplankton change after oxygenation?

Not significantly. Rotifers averaged 29 per liter before and 50 per liter after, an increase confined to the early years, and crustaceans went from 9.4 to 12 per liter; the authors found neither change statistically significant. (PDF page 12) (opens in a new tab)

In Full

More of the Summary

Two more paragraphs of our summary.

The cone pumps 0.9 m³/s of bottom water and began with 8 tons of oxygen a day; operators later held bottom DO above 2 mg/L with only 2 tons a day by 2004. Because the plume hugs the bed with no rising bubbles, bottom nutrients were not carried to the surface.

Chlorophyll a dropped from 14.6 to 3.1 µg/L and Secchi depth rose from 0.47 to 4.9 m, with a single reading of 10 m in June 2004. October bottom-water phosphate fell from 95 to 15 µg P/L and ammonium from 706 to 28 µg N/L, and, unexpectedly, nitrate did not rise. Late-winter surface TP fell 58% and inorganic nitrogen 88%, leaving algae nitrogen-limited. Aphanizomenon and Dolichospermum cyanobacteria fell more than 95%, the diatom Fragilaria more than 90%, and the clean-water indicator Merismopedia appeared. Zooplankton were essentially unchanged. The authors conclude that HOS reliably reduces eutrophication where internal loading drives it.

More Key Figures

Five more, each with what it measures and its PDF page.

From the PDF

FigureWhat It Measures
95 to 15 µg P/L
October soluble phosphate in bottom water, before HOS and in the first years after (PDF page 7 (opens in a new tab))
706 µg N/L
October bottom-water ammonium before HOS, falling to 28 after (PDF page 9 (opens in a new tab))
>95%
Drop in Aphanizomenon and Dolichospermum cyanobacteria (PDF page 2 (opens in a new tab))
198 to 23 µg/L
Late-winter surface total inorganic nitrogen, before HOS and in 2004 (PDF page 13 (opens in a new tab))
8 to 2 tons of oxygen a day
Oxygen supply at start-up and by 2004, as algae declined (PDF page 7 (opens in a new tab))

How to Cite

One line to paste into a report.

Alex J. Horne and Marc Beutel. Hypolimnetic Oxygenation 3: An Engineered Switch from Eutrophic to a Meso-/Oligotrophic State in a California Reservoir. Lake and Reservoir Management, September 2019. https://doi.org/10.1080/10402381.2019.1648613 Project engineer: Brown and Caldwell, R.E. Speece. Eco Oxygen Technologies Technical Library. https://eco2tech.com/technical-library/hypolimnetic-oxygenation-3-an-engineered-switch-from-eutrophic-to-a-meso-oligotrophic-state-in-a-california-reservoir/

https://eco2tech.com/technical-library/hypolimnetic-oxygenation-3-an-engineered-switch-from-eutrophic-to-a-meso-oligotrophic-state-in-a-california-reservoir/

The Next Step

Ask an ECO₂ Engineer

Questions about this technical paper, or about your own water? An application engineer answers, with the figures.

Lake Hodges, a reservoir among dry hills near San Diego, California