Hypolimnetic Oxygenation 1: Win-Win Solution for Massive Salmonid Mortalities in a Reservoir Tailwater Hatchery on the Mokelumne River, California
A paper on the Mokelumne River hatchery below Camanche Reservoir, where fish kills in a drought led to oxygenating the reservoir's bottom water with a Speece Cone®.
Details
Summary
Alex J. Horne's 2019 paper in Lake and Reservoir Management explains how a Speece Cone hypolimnetic oxygenation system (HOS) ended the fish kills at the Mokelumne River hatchery below EBMUD's Camanche Reservoir in California. More than 300,000 young salmon and steelhead died during the 1987 to 1992 drought, most likely poisoned by hydrogen sulfide (H₂S) in the anoxic bottom water the hatchery drew.
Key Figures
300,000fish
Young hatchery salmon and steelhead killed in the 1987 and 1989 events Source: PDF page 2 (opens in a new tab)
8tons of oxygen a day
Oxygen need the HOS was designed for, from measured DO decline and estimated sediment demand Source: PDF page 5 (opens in a new tab)
24years
Without fish kills since the HOS started (to publication) Source: PDF page 2 (opens in a new tab)
Questions
What killed the hatchery fish below Camanche Reservoir?
Hydrogen sulfide (H₂S) from the anoxic bottom water was the most likely cause: the deaths were rapid, H₂S odor was smelled at the hatchery, and gill damage and fish behavior matched H₂S poisoning. Twelve other possibilities, including low reservoir level, were ruled out. (PDF page 14) (opens in a new tab)
Why did aeration at the hatchery not prevent the fish kills?
Aeration vents only part of the dissolved H₂S gas and not the sulfide ion, and oxidizing sulfide to sulfate takes time. Tests showed 6 to 12 hours of aeration were needed to remove detectable H₂S, but water reached the fish less than 5 minutes after aeration. (PDF page 9) (opens in a new tab)
How does the Camanche Reservoir Speece Cone work?
A 0.9 m³/s submersible pump lifts low-oxygen bottom water to the top of a 7 m high cone, where it flows down against rising pure oxygen bubbles until they dissolve. The oxygenated water leaves through a diffuser 4.5 m above the bed, entrains more than 10 times its volume, spreads up to 9 m above the sediments and drifts up the reservoir at about 0.1 cm/s. (PDF page 5) (opens in a new tab)
What is the minimum cool pool rule at Camanche Reservoir?
Overturn came once bottom water near the dam passed 16.4 °C, so discharges now stop when the stable pool below that temperature is down to 31 million m³ (25,000 acre-feet). There have been no unwanted early turnovers in the 24 years since. (PDF page 12) (opens in a new tab)
Why was oxygenation chosen over permanganate or higher reservoir levels?
Permanganate removed H₂S but was expensive, and its brown precipitate and slime would smother eggs in the hatchery. Holding more water in the reservoir would have cut flows downstream, while the HOS gives high-quality outflow even when less water is stored. (PDF page 12) (opens in a new tab)
In Full
More of the Summary
Two more paragraphs of our summary.
With no limnological data available, the toxin was deduced from sediment redox readings, H₂S odor and a ranking of thirteen possible causes. Hatchery aeration raised dissolved oxygen from under 0.5 mg/L to 8.6 to 9.2 mg/L, yet fish still died: tests showed H₂S needs 6 to 12 hours of aeration to clear, while water reached the fish in under 5 minutes. A 7 m high cone near the dam, fed by a 0.9 m³/s pump and sized for 8 tons of oxygen a day, now lays a cool, oxygenated plume over the sediments so H₂S never forms. An operating rule also keeps a cool pool of 31 million m³ below 16.4 °C to prevent early overturn.
After oxygenation, fish spread from a narrow band at the thermocline through the whole water column. Drought-year returns rose from 786 to 7,963 a year, and endangered steelhead, absent from 1976 to 1992, totaled 1,168 in 2018. The HOS outperformed permanganate dosing and higher reservoir levels, and the criminal case against the utility was dropped.
More Key Figures
Four more, each with what it measures and its PDF page.
From the PDF
| Figure | What It Measures |
|---|---|
| 19,867 Chinook salmon | Record return in 2018, of which more than 10,000 spawned in the river (PDF page 11 (opens in a new tab)) |
| 1,168 steelhead | Endangered steelhead returns in 2018, up from zero in 1976 to 1992 (PDF page 10 (opens in a new tab)) |
| 786 to 7,963 Chinook salmon a year | Average returns in drought years, before and after the HOS (PDF page 11 (opens in a new tab)) |
| 31 million m³ | Minimum cool pool (water below 16.4 °C) kept in the reservoir to prevent early overturn (PDF page 12 (opens in a new tab)) |
How to Cite
One line to paste into a report.
Alex J. Horne. Hypolimnetic Oxygenation 1: Win-Win Solution for Massive Salmonid Mortalities in a Reservoir Tailwater Hatchery on the Mokelumne River, California. Lake and Reservoir Management, August 2019. https://doi.org/10.1080/10402381.2019.1649770 Project engineer: Brown and Caldwell, Ford Construction, Pan Marine Construction, R.E. Speece. Eco Oxygen Technologies Technical Library. https://eco2tech.com/technical-library/hypolimnetic-oxygenation-1-win-win-solution-for-massive-salmonid-mortalities-in-a-reservoir-tailwater-hatchery-on-the-mokelumne-river-california/
https://eco2tech.com/technical-library/hypolimnetic-oxygenation-1-win-win-solution-for-massive-salmonid-mortalities-in-a-reservoir-tailwater-hatchery-on-the-mokelumne-river-california/
The Next Step
Ask an ECO₂ Engineer
Questions about this technical paper, or about your own water? An application engineer answers, with the figures.
