Superoxygenation for Environmental Enhancement in Wastewater Collection & Treatment
Bacteria use up the oxygen in wastewater faster than the air can replace it, so sewers and plants turn anaerobic and make hydrogen sulfide and methane.
Details
Summary
Stopping H₂S & Methane Before They Form
R. E. Speece and ECO₂'s David Clidence show where dissolving pure oxygen prevents both, from force mains to final effluent. Methane matters most: once formed, it escapes (p. 3).
Key Figures
12,800t CO₂e/yr
Annual sewer methane emissions across DC Water's collection system (almost) Source: PDF page 3 (opens in a new tab)
$100per ton
Approximate cost of high purity oxygen Source: PDF page 4 (opens in a new tab)
12,800MT CO₂e a year
Sewer methane across DC Water's collection system (almost) Source: PDF page 3 (opens in a new tab)
Questions
Does dissolved oxygen prevent methane in sewers?
Yes. Methane forms under anaerobic conditions, so keeping wastewater aerobic stops it. Once formed it is practically not biodegraded in the hours wastewater spends in the system, so prevention is the only practical control (p. 3).
How much oxygen keeps a force main aerobic?
The demand rate times the travel time. For a 4 mile force main with 4 hours of residence at nominally 10 mg/L per hour, the authors raise dissolved oxygen above 40 mg/L at the pump station (pp. 4, 5).
How do you stop rising sludge in a secondary clarifier?
Keep the sludge blanket from running out of oxygen. Raising the mixed liquor entering the clarifier to 10 to 20 mg/L of dissolved oxygen prevents the denitrification whose nitrogen bubbles float the sludge (p. 6).
Can dissolved oxygen offset BOD in a plant's effluent?
Yes. Oxygen equal to the effluent's ultimate BOD, for example 30 mg/L for 30 mg/L, means the receiving river's oxygen is not used, which may avoid costly tertiary treatment (p. 7).
Why is methane harder to deal with than hydrogen sulfide?
Hydrogen sulfide is readily broken down once conditions turn aerobic, but methane is practically not biodegraded in the hours wastewater spends in the system, so nearly all that forms escapes; it has to be prevented. (PDF page 3) (opens in a new tab)
In Full
More Key Figures
Six more, each with what it measures and its PDF page.
From the PDF
| Figure | What It Measures |
|---|---|
| 50% | Share of DC Water's Scope 1 greenhouse gas from sewer methane (at least) (PDF page 3 (opens in a new tab)) |
| 100 seconds | Contact time an oxygen bubble needs for efficient absorption (about) (PDF page 4 (opens in a new tab)) |
| 40 mg/L | Dissolved oxygen at the pump station to keep a 4 mile, 4 hour force main aerobic (over) (PDF page 4 (opens in a new tab)) |
| 20 mg/L | Dissolved oxygen into a primary clarifier with 2 hours of detention (over) (PDF page 6 (opens in a new tab)) |
| 10 to 20 mg/L | Mixed liquor dissolved oxygen that prevents rising sludge in the secondary clarifier (PDF page 6 (opens in a new tab)) |
| 30 mg/L | Dissolved oxygen that offsets 30 mg/L of effluent ultimate BOD (PDF page 7 (opens in a new tab)) |
The Full Write-Up
The problem, the work, the results and who did it.
Anaerobic Wastewater Makes Two Pollutants, & Only One Can Be Undone
Bacteria in wastewater feed on its organic load (BOD) and use dissolved oxygen faster than contact with the air can put it back. The water turns anaerobic, and two of the worst products follow: hydrogen sulfide (H₂S), which causes severe odor and corrosion, and methane, a potent greenhouse gas (p. 3).
Sewer methane adds up. The authors cite a study of DC Water's whole collection system in Washington: its sewer methane came to almost 12,800 MT of CO₂ equivalent a year, at least 50% of the utility's Scope 1 greenhouse gas emissions (p. 3).
The two gases behave differently once formed. Up to 100 mg/L of dissolved H₂S can be completely biodegraded in oxic wastewater in about 30 minutes. Methane, for practical purposes, cannot. Over the few hours wastewater spends in collection and treatment, essentially all of it escapes to the air, and capturing it is impractical. The only practical answer is to stop it forming (p. 3).
Pure Oxygen, a Trapped Bubble Swarm & Pressure
Superoxygenation uses pure oxygen instead of air, with pressure and a captive, intense bubble swarm, to raise dissolved oxygen far above what air can give while keeping it in solution (p. 3). High purity oxygen costs money, whether made on site or trucked in as liquid oxygen, so it must be absorbed efficiently (p. 4).
An oxygen bubble must stay in contact with water for about 100 seconds to be absorbed efficiently, the same as injection into a 100 ft deep water column. The Speece Cone® gets that contact time by holding the bubble swarm in place. Its large gas to water surface also strips essentially no H₂S or methane out of the wastewater (p. 4).
Pressure helps in proportion: the higher the pressure on the bubble swarm, the more oxygen the water can hold. A cone fed by a side stream at the head of a force main works at the force main's own pressure (p. 4).
The authors put oxygen at about a tenth of the cost of other chemical oxidants for H₂S, such as nitrate, hydrogen peroxide and iron salts. Oxygen can also remove dissolved H₂S completely (pp. 3, 5).
Sized for Each Place in the System, from Force Main to Final Effluent
Force mains hold wastewater without air for hours, and some exceed 8 miles. In a 4 mile force main with 4 hours of residence and an oxygen demand of nominally 10 mg/L per hour, raising dissolved oxygen above 40 mg/L at the pump station keeps the whole main aerobic (pp. 4, 5). An installation in Missouri adds 180 mg/L in the cone discharge to a force main with 180 ft of head, still below saturation at that pressure, so none bubbles out (p. 6).
At a primary clarifier, with a demand of 10 mg/L per hour and 2 hours of detention, raising the raw wastewater above 20 mg/L oxidizes the H₂S present and prevents more H₂S and methane. Covering the clarifier instead leaves methane untreated and complicates maintenance (p. 6).
In the secondary clarifier, the aeration tank sends only about 2 mg/L. Raising the mixed liquor to 10 to 20 mg/L stops the denitrification that floats rising sludge, and as much as 40 mg/L keeps the sludge blanket oxic throughout, adding treatment capacity without new tanks (pp. 6, 7).
At the outfall, adding 30 mg/L of dissolved oxygen to an effluent with 30 mg/L of ultimate BOD spares the river's oxygen. A Georgia plant whose new permit required up to 30 mg/L installed Superoxygenation rather than spend about $2 million more on tertiary treatment or reverse osmosis (pp. 7, 8).
Written by R. E. Speece and ECO₂'s President, David Clidence
R. E. Speece is Centennial Professor of Environmental Engineering Emeritus at Vanderbilt University. David Clidence is president of Eco Oxygen Technologies, LLC (ECO₂). The article appeared in Texas WET, the magazine of the Water Environment Association of Texas, in Issue 4 of 2024 (pp. 2, 3). Its installation examples are named by state only.
Why It Matters for a Utility Counting Its Emissions
Most odor work treats H₂S. This paper adds the case for methane: the same dissolved oxygen that stops H₂S also stops methane forming, and methane cannot be cleaned up afterward (p. 3).
The sizing rule is the same at every step: the oxygen demand rate times the hours the water must stay aerobic. The authors also find pure oxygen cheaper than air as a source when the target exceeds nominally 6 mg/L (pp. 4, 6, 8).
Written up from the published article. Every figure is as the published article prints it, with the PDF page it comes from; the authors' own words appear only in quotation marks.
How to Cite
One line to paste into a report.
R. E. Speece and David Clidence. Superoxygenation for Environmental Enhancement in Wastewater Collection & Treatment. Water Environment Association of Texas (WEAT), 2024. Eco Oxygen Technologies Technical Library. https://eco2tech.com/technical-library/superoxygenation-for-environmental-enhancement-in-wastewater-collection-treatment/
https://eco2tech.com/technical-library/superoxygenation-for-environmental-enhancement-in-wastewater-collection-treatment/
The Next Step
Ask an ECO₂ Engineer
Questions about this published article, or about your own water? An application engineer answers, with the figures.
