Sewer Methane Green House Gas Accounting

A WEF webinar arguing that sewers give off far more methane than greenhouse gas protocols assume, with a way to estimate it from a utility's hydraulic model.

Details

Publisher
WEF
Published
November 2018
Authors
John Willis, Keshab Sharma, Asbjørn Haaning Nielsen, Wendy Barrott

Summary

Estimating the Methane Sewers Emit

Greenhouse gas protocols assume sewers in the developed world emit no methane. In this November 2018 WEF webinar, the presenters argue sewer methane is over half of U.S. centralized wastewater Scope 1 emissions, and show two equations that estimate it from a utility's own hydraulic model (pp. 1, 4, 5, 9).

Key Figures

Questions

Do sewers produce methane?

Yes. Biofilm on sewer walls gives methane-forming microbes a long residence time in its deeper layers. The presenters' research suggests sewer methane is over half of U.S. centralized wastewater Scope 1 emissions (pp. 5, 7).

Why do greenhouse gas protocols ignore sewer methane?

Because it is small nationally. Sewer methane is 1 million metric tons of CO₂ equivalent a year, 0.015% of U.S. emissions of 7.0 billion (p. 6).

How do you estimate methane from a force main?

With the force main and surcharged sewer equation: 3.452 × D × 1.06^(T−20) kg of methane per km per day, where D is the pipe diameter in meters and T the temperature in °C (p. 9).

Does sulfide control reduce methane in force mains?

In a Danish pilot it did. Over 200 m, methane rose 4.23 mg/L untreated, about 0 with ferrous iron and 1.91 mg/L with ferric iron (p. 35).

Do sewers emit methane?

Yes. Protocols such as the IPCC's assume no sewer methane in the developed world, but this research suggests it is over half of U.S. centralized wastewater Scope 1 emissions. (PDF page 4) (opens in a new tab)

Why have protocols ignored it?

On a national scale it is small: sewer methane is about 1 million metric tons of CO₂e a year, 0.015% of U.S. emissions of about 7.0 billion. (PDF page 6) (opens in a new tab)

How does the method work?

It applies one empirical equation to gravity sewer segments (temperature, flow, diameter, slope) and another to force main and surcharged segments (diameter, temperature), using the utility's hydraulic model at average flow. (PDF page 9) (opens in a new tab)

How accurate is it?

For a force main network the model was 0.73% under measured methane in winter and 23.49% under in summer; a Danish pilot force main also matched well. (PDF page 30) (opens in a new tab)

Does sulfide control affect methane?

Yes. In the Danish pilot, ferrous or ferric iron dosing for sulfide control lowered methane formation significantly. (PDF page 36) (opens in a new tab)

In Full

More Key Figures

10 more, each with what it measures and its PDF page.

From the PDF

FigureWhat It Measures
23.49% difference
Force main method against measured methane, summer data (under-predicted) (PDF page 30 (opens in a new tab))
4.23 mg CH₄/L
Methane produced over 200 m of untreated pilot force main, against about 0 with ferrous iron (PDF page 35 (opens in a new tab))
240 t CH₄/yr
Great Lakes Water Authority's estimated annual sewer methane (PDF page 42 (opens in a new tab))
6,700 t CO₂e/yr
GLWA sewer methane at a global warming potential of 28 (5,000 at 21) (PDF page 42 (opens in a new tab))
50% of Scope 1
Sewer methane's share of U.S. centralized wastewater Scope 1 emissions (over; the presenters' research) (PDF page 5 (opens in a new tab))
0.015% of U.S. emissions
Sewer methane's share of total U.S. greenhouse gas emissions (PDF page 6 (opens in a new tab))
23.49%
Force main model below measured methane, summer (0.73% in winter) (PDF page 30 (opens in a new tab))
4.23 mg CH₄/L
Methane produced over 200 m of an untreated pilot force main (about 0 with ferrous iron) (PDF page 35 (opens in a new tab))
240 t CH₄/yr
Great Lakes Water Authority's estimated sewer methane (PDF page 42 (opens in a new tab))
6,700 t CO₂e/yr
The same at a global warming potential of 28 (5,000 at 21) (PDF page 42 (opens in a new tab))

The Full Write-Up

The problem, the work, the results and who did it.

Protocols Count Sewer Methane as Zero

The IPCC and other greenhouse gas protocols assume there is no methane from sewers in the developed world. The presenters' research suggests that for utilities the opposite is true: over half of the U.S. centralized wastewater industry's Scope 1 emissions come from sewer methane (pp. 4, 5).

The presenters reconcile the two by scale. U.S. greenhouse gas emissions are 7.0 billion metric tons of CO₂ equivalent a year. All wastewater is 41 million (0.59%), centralized wastewater 24 million (0.34%) and sewer methane 1 million (0.015%) (p. 6). Small for the country, large in a utility's own account.

The methane comes from slime layers. Biofilm gives methane-forming microbes a long residence time in its deeper layers, while sulfide reducers are more prominent near its surface. Some flow is needed to carry carbon and sulfate into the biofilm, and sediments do not normally contribute (p. 7).

Two Equations, Applied Segment by Segment

The method uses two empirical equations, applied to each segment of a collection system model run at average flow. For gravity sewers, methane per kilometer per day depends on temperature, flow, pipe diameter and slope. For force mains and surcharged sewers it depends only on diameter and temperature: 3.452 × D × 1.06^(T−20) kg of methane per km per day. A segment with the hydraulic grade below the crown at both ends counts as gravity, above at both ends as surcharged, and one that crosses is split (p. 9). Measured sewage temperatures are best; otherwise a correlation to commonly measured temperatures can stand in (p. 10).

The equations come from SeweX, a sewer process model run on over 30 sewer catchments, with full-scale data to calibrate or verify about 30% of them. Regressions of SeweX runs over ranges of pipe size, flow, slope and temperature gave the equations, with parameters calibrated on an Australian sewer (pp. 12, 13).

Checked on a Force Main Network, an Interceptor & a Pilot

On a network of force mains, the model predicted 17.95 kg of methane against 23.46 kg measured in summer, 23.49% low, and came within 0.73% in winter (p. 30).

On the Potomac Interceptor, methane was measured at a foul air fan in September 2014 and April 2015, at sewage temperatures of 21.5 to 22.1°C and 12.1 to 12.7°C. The presenters report good correlation with temperature (pp. 25, 26).

In Denmark, the force main equation predicts a rise of 5.4 mg/L of methane over the first 200 m of a pilot force main, in good agreement with the 4.2 mg/L measured in the untreated line. Iron dosing for sulfide control cut methane too: 4.23 mg/L untreated, about 0 with ferrous iron and 1.91 with ferric iron (p. 35).

The Great Lakes Water Authority, serving 3.5 million people with about 1% force mains, ran the method on its model. It estimates 240 metric tons of methane a year, 5,000 or 6,700 metric tons of CO₂ equivalent at a global warming potential of 21 or 28 (pp. 37, 42).

Presented by a Consultant, Two Universities & a Utility

The presenters are John Willis of Brown and Caldwell, Keshab Sharma of the University of Queensland in Australia, Asbjørn Haaning Nielsen of Aalborg University in Denmark, and Wendy Barrott of the Great Lakes Water Authority in Michigan. Christine Radke of The Water Research Foundation moderated, and staff of DC Water contributed (pp. 2, 3).

What It Means for a Utility's Greenhouse Gas Account

If your utility reports Scope 1 emissions, this method puts a number on a source the protocols leave at zero, using your hydraulic model and sewage temperatures (pp. 4, 9, 10). The force main equation shows what drives it: the rate per kilometer rises with pipe diameter and temperature (p. 9).

The webinar does not test dissolved oxygen. Its Danish data show that changing a force main's chemistry for sulfide control changed its methane too (pp. 35, 36). ECO₂'s own paper on sewer greenhouse gas formation is linked below.

Written up from the presentation. Every figure is as the presentation prints it, with the PDF page it comes from; the authors' own words appear only in quotation marks.

How to Cite

One line to paste into a report.

John Willis, Keshab Sharma, Asbjørn Haaning Nielsen and Wendy Barrott. Sewer Methane Green House Gas Accounting. WEF, November 2018. Project engineer: Brown and Caldwell. Eco Oxygen Technologies Technical Library. https://eco2tech.com/technical-library/sewer-methane-green-house-gas-accounting/

https://eco2tech.com/technical-library/sewer-methane-green-house-gas-accounting/

The Next Step

Ask an ECO₂ Engineer

Questions about this presentation, or about your own water? An application engineer answers, with the figures.

A rebuilt sewage pump station with a planted roof beside Lake Sammamish