Role of Sediment and Internal Loading of Phosphorus in Shallow Lakes

A review of why a shallow lake can stay murky after its phosphorus inflow is cut: the sediment stores phosphorus and keeps releasing it into the water.

Details

Publisher
Hydrobiologia
Published
2003
Authors
Martin Søndergaard, Jens Peder Jensen, Erik Jeppesen
Engineer
National Environmental Research Institute of Denmark

Summary

Why Shallow Lakes Stay Murky

Cutting the phosphorus that flows into a shallow lake may not clear it, because phosphorus stored in the sediment keeps coming back. In this 2003 review, Danish researchers note that the sediment pool is often more than 100 times the pool in the water, and that release can continue for decades (pp. 1, 2).

Key Figures

Questions

Why doesn't a lake improve after phosphorus inflows are cut?

Phosphorus stored in the sediment during years of heavy loading keeps being released. Internal loading can last at least 10 years, and in some lakes retention stays negative for 20 years or more (pp. 4, 5).

What is internal phosphorus loading?

Phosphorus released back into the water from a lake's own sediment. It shows as summer phosphorus well above winter levels, by 200 to 300% in the most eutrophic lakes (p. 2).

What iron to phosphorus ratio keeps phosphorus in lake sediment?

The paper cites retention staying high while the Fe:P ratio is above 15 by weight with the surface sediment kept oxidized. Another study suggests above 10 (p. 6).

Does wind resuspension release phosphorus in shallow lakes?

Not necessarily. In Lake Vest Stadil Fjord, suspended solids and total phosphorus rose by a factor of 5 to 10 within a few days of wind, with little or no lasting rise in phosphorus afterward (p. 5).

Can removing fish reduce internal phosphorus loading?

In Lake Engelsholm, removing 66% of the fish cleared the water, cut negative summer retention from 6 to 4 months and turned annual net retention positive (p. 3).

Why do some lakes not improve after phosphorus inflows are cut?

Phosphorus accumulated in the sediment during heavy loading keeps being released, so internal loading can hold concentrations up and retention can stay negative for years or even decades. (PDF page 1) (opens in a new tab)

When is internal loading strongest?

In summer: in the most eutrophic lakes summer concentrations typically exceed winter levels by 200 to 300% from June to October, and retention is negative for part of the summer. (PDF page 2) (opens in a new tab)

What role does iron play?

In oxidized sediment phosphorus binds to iron(III); under anoxia iron is reduced and both iron and phosphate return to solution. Retention stays high while the Fe:P ratio exceeds about 15 by weight and the surface sediment is kept oxidized. (PDF page 6) (opens in a new tab)

Can changing the fish community help?

Yes. In Lake Engelsholm, removing 66% of the fish cleared the water, shortened summer negative retention from 6 to 4 months and turned annual net retention from negative to positive. (PDF page 3) (opens in a new tab)

What restoration methods reduce internal loading?

Removing phosphorus rich surface sediment or adding iron, alum or calcium to raise sorption capacity, provided the external load has first been cut enough. (PDF page 8) (opens in a new tab)

In Full

More Key Figures

11 more, each with what it measures and its PDF page.

From the PDF

FigureWhat It Measures
66% of fish stock
Fish removed in the Lake Engelsholm biomanipulation (PDF page 3 (opens in a new tab))
15 Fe:P by weight
Iron to phosphorus ratio above which sediment retention stays high when oxidized (PDF page 6 (opens in a new tab))
20 cm
Sediment depth from which phosphorus can still be released (PDF page 1 (opens in a new tab))
1% of sediment P
Share of the sediment's total phosphorus held in interstitial water (less than) (PDF page 7 (opens in a new tab))
More than 100 times
Sediment phosphorus pool compared with the pool in the lake water (often) (PDF page 2 (opens in a new tab))
200 to 300%
How far summer phosphorus exceeds winter levels in the most eutrophic lakes, June to October (PDF page 2 (opens in a new tab))
5 months
Summer net phosphorus release in Danish lakes above 0.2 mg P/L, against 2 months below 0.1 (PDF page 2 (opens in a new tab))
15 Fe:P by weight
Iron to phosphorus ratio above which retention stays high in oxidized sediment (PDF page 6 (opens in a new tab))
20 to 25 cm
Sediment depth from which phosphorus has been seen to move (PDF page 4 (opens in a new tab))
More than 30 years
Estimated recovery of Lake Søbygaard after its load was cut (PDF page 4 (opens in a new tab))
66%
Share of the fish stock removed in Lake Engelsholm (PDF page 3 (opens in a new tab))

The Full Write-Up

The problem, the work, the results and who did it.

A Phosphorus Store in the Sediment That Outlasts the Cleanup

Phosphorus is regarded as the most important factor in a lake's water quality. Heavy loading brings dense algae, murky water, the loss of submerged plants and changes in the fish. Some lakes respond fast when the phosphorus flowing in is cut, but many recover slowly, because phosphorus built up in the sediment during the years of heavy loading needs time to come into balance with the lower load (p. 1).

Shallow lakes are a special case. Deep lakes collect phosphorus in their anoxic bottom layer while they are stratified. Shallow lakes are usually well mixed and oxygenated top to bottom, yet their sediment often releases phosphorus into oxic water, and their large sediment area for the volume of water makes the effect stronger (pp. 1, 2).

The signal is in summer. In the most eutrophic lakes, summer phosphorus typically runs 200 to 300% above winter levels from June until October (p. 2).

A Review of Retention, Release & Danish Lake Records

The authors review how lake sediments retain and release phosphorus, drawing on mass balances and sediment profiles from Danish lakes and on the wider literature (p. 2).

In a study of 16 Danish lakes, retention was positive in winter whatever the lake's state, and negative for part of the summer. Lakes below 0.1 mg P/L released more than they received for 2 months in midsummer, and lakes above 0.2 mg P/L for 5 months (p. 2).

They then review the release mechanisms: wind that stirs up sediment, temperature and microbial activity, the redox state of the top layer, pH, the iron to phosphorus ratio, diffusion and burrowing animals, sulfate reduction and rooted plants (pp. 5, 6, 7).

Iron, Oxygen & Microbes Drive Most of the Release

In oxidized sediment, phosphorus binds to iron(III) compounds. Under anoxia, iron(III) is reduced to iron(II), and both the iron and the phosphate sorbed to it go back into solution (p. 5). Retention stays high while the iron to phosphorus ratio is above 15 by weight, and above that ratio internal loading may be prevented by keeping the surface sediment oxidized. Another study puts it at 10 (p. 6).

But the oxic layer is thin. Oxygen typically reaches a few millimeters into the sediment, nitrate several centimeters (p. 7). In eutrophic lakes with organic-rich sediment, the oxic surface layer is often too thin to stop release from deeper down (p. 8).

Phosphorus can move from as deep as 20 to 25 cm, and internal loading can last at least 10 years after the external load is cut. In some lakes retention stays negative for 20 years or more (pp. 4, 5). Lake Søbygaard's external load was cut by 80 to 90% in 1982. After 20 years its annual retention was still negative, and full recovery is estimated at more than 30 years (p. 4).

Biology matters too. In Lake Engelsholm, removing 66% of the fish cleared the water, cut summer negative retention from 6 to 4 months and turned annual net retention from minus 2.5 to plus 3.3 g of phosphorus per square meter a year (p. 3).

Written by Three Danish Freshwater Ecologists

Martin Søndergaard, Jens Peder Jensen and Erik Jeppesen of the National Environmental Research Institute's Department of Freshwater Ecology in Silkeborg, Denmark, wrote the review. It appeared in Hydrobiologia, volumes 506 to 509, pages 135 to 145, in 2003 (p. 1). The EU project BUFFER partly funded the work, and local county authorities supplied some of the data (p. 8).

What It Means for a Lake That Will Not Clear

If your lake still grows summer blooms after its inflow was cleaned up, this paper explains why, and why it can take decades to pass (p. 1).

Its central mechanism is the one hypolimnetic oxygenation relies on in lakes that stratify: phosphorus bound to iron stays in sediment that has oxygen and comes out when the sediment goes anoxic, provided the sediment holds enough iron (pp. 5, 6). The paper itself does not test oxygenation. Its restoration list is dredging out phosphorus-rich sediment and adding iron, alum or calcium, and it says every method needs the outside load cut enough first (p. 8).

Because release is partly lake specific, start with your own lake: summer phosphorus against winter, bottom oxygen, and the iron to phosphorus ratio near the sediment surface.

Written up from the technical paper. Every figure is as the technical paper prints it, with the PDF page it comes from; the authors' own words appear only in quotation marks.

How to Cite

One line to paste into a report.

Martin Søndergaard, Jens Peder Jensen and Erik Jeppesen. Role of Sediment and Internal Loading of Phosphorus in Shallow Lakes. Hydrobiologia, 2003. Project engineer: National Environmental Research Institute of Denmark. Eco Oxygen Technologies Technical Library. https://eco2tech.com/technical-library/role-of-sediment-and-internal-loading-of-phosphorus-in-shallow-lakes/

https://eco2tech.com/technical-library/role-of-sediment-and-internal-loading-of-phosphorus-in-shallow-lakes/

The Next Step

Ask an ECO₂ Engineer

Questions about this technical paper, or about your own water? An application engineer answers, with the figures.

Lake Hodges, a reservoir among dry hills near San Diego, California