Water Environment Technology - July 2024 - Sustainable Sewers
A WE&T feature by V&A Consulting Engineers on designing sewers that stay aerobic, with fewer force mains and shorter detention, so they make less H₂S and methane.
Details
Summary
Sewers Designed to Stay Aerobic
Hydrogen sulfide and methane both form when wastewater in a sewer runs out of oxygen. In this feature, Vaughan Harshman and Chris Hunniford of V&A Consulting Engineers explain why and how to design against it: fewer force mains, shorter detention, clean lines, oxygen or chemicals where needed and less turbulence (pp. 2, 4, 8, 9, 13).
Key Figures
7.1pH
Below this pH more sulfide shifts to volatile hydrogen sulfide Source: PDF page 3 (opens in a new tab)
28CO₂ equivalent
Global warming potential of methane relative to carbon dioxide Source: PDF page 4 (opens in a new tab)
14.5:1CO₂e to carbon
Greenhouse impact of carbon broken down by sulfate reduction, against 1:1 with oxygen or nitrate Source: PDF page 5 (opens in a new tab)
Questions
Why do force mains produce hydrogen sulfide?
A force main has a 360 degree wetted surface and no headspace for oxygen transfer, so it quickly uses up its dissolved oxygen. Bacteria in the slime layer then use sulfate and make sulfide (pp. 2, 3, 8).
Does pH affect hydrogen sulfide release from wastewater?
Yes. Below a pH of 7.1 more of the sulfide is in the volatile hydrogen sulfide form, which can escape to the air. Above 7.1 more stays in solution as ions (p. 3).
Do sewers produce methane?
Yes, from the same anaerobic processes that make hydrogen sulfide. Previous research puts collection system methane at 45% of the wastewater sector's direct greenhouse gas emissions (pp. 4, 6).
Does sewer corrosion cause sewer overflows?
It contributes. Of U.S. overflows not caused by wet weather, 36% come from line breaks, and many of those are due to corrosion from hydrogen sulfide and sulfuric acid (p. 6).
What drives hydrogen sulfide release in sewers?
Four factors: dissolved sulfide concentration, pH, temperature and turbulence. (PDF page 2) (opens in a new tab)
Why does pH matter?
Above pH 7.1 more sulfide stays in nonvolatile ionic forms; below 7.1 more becomes hydrogen sulfide gas that can escape to the air. (PDF page 3) (opens in a new tab)
Why are force mains a problem?
They have a fully wetted surface and no headspace for oxygen transfer, so they quickly use up dissolved oxygen and turn anaerobic. (PDF page 8) (opens in a new tab)
How much methane comes from sewers?
Previous research puts collection system methane at 45% of the wastewater sector's direct greenhouse gas emissions; abating it could reduce global methane emissions by 2%. (PDF page 6) (opens in a new tab)
What can designers do?
Limit anaerobic conditions by favoring gravity sewers, limiting detention time, keeping lines clean and treating where needed; minimize turbulence; enforce pretreatment; design for growth; use corrosion resistant materials and ventilation. (PDF page 8) (opens in a new tab)
In Full
More Key Figures
10 more, each with what it measures and its PDF page.
From the PDF
| Figure | What It Measures |
|---|---|
| 3 billion to 10 billion gal/year | Sanitary sewer overflows in the U.S. (EPA estimate) (PDF page 6 (opens in a new tab)) |
| 36% of dry weather overflows | Share of non wet weather overflows caused by line breaks (PDF page 6 (opens in a new tab)) |
| 45% of sector direct emissions | Collection system share of the wastewater sector's direct greenhouse gas emissions (PDF page 6 (opens in a new tab)) |
| 2% of global methane | Reduction possible by abating collection system methane (PDF page 6 (opens in a new tab)) |
| 28 CO₂ equivalent | Global warming potential of methane, against 1 for carbon dioxide (PDF page 4 (opens in a new tab)) |
| 14.5:1 CO₂e to carbon | Carbon broken down with sulfate (1:1 with oxygen or nitrate) (PDF page 5 (opens in a new tab)) |
| 7.1 pH | Below this, more sulfide is in the volatile hydrogen sulfide form (PDF page 3 (opens in a new tab)) |
| 3 billion to 10 billion gal a year | Sanitary sewer overflows in the U.S. (EPA estimate) (PDF page 6 (opens in a new tab)) |
| 36% | Of overflows not caused by wet weather that come from line breaks (PDF page 6 (opens in a new tab)) |
| 45% | Collection systems' share of the wastewater sector's direct greenhouse gas emissions (previous research) (PDF page 6 (opens in a new tab)) |
The Full Write-Up
The problem, the work, the results and who did it.
The Sewer Is a Bioreactor, & Anaerobic Stretches Make Two Harmful Gases
Sewer designers focus on hydraulics. The authors argue that the biology and chemistry in a sewer are often overlooked, and that left alone they lead to corrosion, odor, hazardous work conditions and harm to the treatment plant downstream (p. 2).
Hydrogen sulfide is almost always formed inside the collection system, not brought in by the source flows. Bacteria in the slime layer on every wetted surface break down organic matter using sulfate once oxygen and nitrate are gone. Sulfate is usually plentiful, so the amount of sulfide depends on how many of these bacteria there are and how long the wastewater is exposed to them. Debris and grit grow slime too (pp. 2, 3).
Three more factors decide how much escapes as gas. Below a pH of 7.1 more sulfide is in the volatile hydrogen sulfide form; above it, more stays in solution as ions. Warm wastewater makes more sulfide, so levels peak in summer. Turbulence releases more gas into the air (pp. 3, 4).
Methane comes from the same anaerobic processes. It is nearly insoluble, so once formed it escapes quickly, and it is 28 times more potent than carbon dioxide as a greenhouse gas (p. 4).
Design the System to Limit Anaerobic Conditions
The authors' first rule is to limit anaerobic conditions, which cuts hydrogen sulfide, corrosion and methane together (p. 8).
Minimize force mains and favor gravity sewers. A force main has a 360 degree wetted surface and no headspace for oxygen transfer, so it quickly uses up its dissolved oxygen (p. 8). Size pipes for the expected flow but no larger, since oversizing lengthens detention time. Clean and flush lines to cut the slime bacteria. Where anaerobic conditions cannot be avoided, ventilate and treat the air, or treat the wastewater with chemicals or oxygen, and weigh every environmental effect, greenhouse gases included, not only the H₂S (p. 9).
Minimize turbulence, especially at and below force main discharges, with pump stations that run at the inlet level, drop pipes in wet wells and manholes, and wye connections in place of tees (pp. 9, 10). Enforce industrial pretreatment limits. Plan for the low flows of a new branch with parallel pipes, pumps of several sizes, or chemical addition that can be phased out as flows grow (p. 10). Use corrosion resistant materials where headspace meets H₂S, and use ventilation to pull H₂S out of the headspace and contain odor (pp. 11, 12).
What Is at Stake: Overflows, Methane & Odor
This is a design article with no project data. It sets out the stakes in environmental, social and governance terms (p. 5).
EPA estimates 3 billion to 10 billion gal of sanitary sewer overflows a year in the U.S. Of the overflows not caused by wet weather, 36% come from line breaks, many from hydrogen sulfide and sulfuric acid corrosion. If corrosion causes 50% of line breaks, the authors estimate corrosion control could prevent 0.5 billion to nearly 2 billion gal of overflows a year (p. 6).
Water infrastructure is estimated to produce 4.7% of global methane emissions, and collection systems 45% of the wastewater sector's direct greenhouse gas emissions. So, the authors write, abating sewer methane could cut global methane emissions by 2% (p. 6). The carbon arithmetic favors aerobic sewers: carbon broken down with oxygen or nitrate gives a 1:1 ratio of carbon dioxide to carbon, while with sulfate the result is 14.5:1 in carbon dioxide equivalent (p. 5).
Odor matters too. People react to a foul smell emotionally even when it is harmless, and both overflows and odor can bring enforcement action (p. 7).
Written by Two Engineers at V&A Consulting Engineers
Vaughan Harshman is Odor Control Lead in the Manchester, New Hampshire office, and Chris Hunniford is Chief Operating Officer in the Houston office of V&A Consulting Engineers, based in Oakland, California (p. 13). The library lists the feature under Water Environment & Technology. It describes no single utility's system and does not name ECO₂ or its equipment.
What It Means If a Force Main Cannot Be Avoided
For a force main that has to stay, the article's advice is to treat the cause, the missing oxygen, and to count methane as well as H₂S when choosing how (p. 9). While dissolved oxygen or nitrate is present, the aerobic zone of the slime layer keeps sulfide from reaching the flow (pp. 2, 3).
Superoxygenation is one way to supply it: a Speece Cone® dissolves pure oxygen into a side stream, so the main carries it with no bubbles. The article assesses no product; ECO₂'s force main papers report measured results.
Written up from the published article. Every figure is as the published article prints it, with the PDF page it comes from; the authors' own words appear only in quotation marks.
How to Cite
One line to paste into a report.
Vaughan Harshman and Chris Hunniford. Water Environment Technology - July 2024 - Sustainable Sewers. Water Environment & Technology, July 2024. Eco Oxygen Technologies Technical Library. https://eco2tech.com/technical-library/water-environment-technology-july-2024-sustainable-sewers/
https://eco2tech.com/technical-library/water-environment-technology-july-2024-sustainable-sewers/
The Next Step
Ask an ECO₂ Engineer
Questions about this published article, or about your own water? An application engineer answers, with the figures.
