TRA Primary Clarifier Superoxygenation System for Odor and Corrosion Control
ECO₂'s case study of the Trinity River Authority's Central Regional plant near Dallas, where oxygen in the incoming wastewater controls primary clarifier odor.
Details
Summary
After a 2003 odor abatement evaluation found clarifier covers and gas scrubbers costly and hazardous, TRA chose ECO₂ Superoxygenation for its Stage VII odor program, designed with Alan Plummer Associates. Unlike force main systems that prevent sulfide, this one oxidizes sulfides already present at 3 to 6 mg/L.
Key Figures
3 to 6mg/L
Dissolved sulfides already present in the incoming wastewater Source: PDF page 2 (opens in a new tab)
60mg/L
Side stream D.O. at the cone discharge Source: PDF page 2 (opens in a new tab)
9,875gpm
Side stream flow per cone Source: PDF page 2 (opens in a new tab)
Questions
Why did TRA choose oxygen over covers and scrubbers?
Its 2003 odor abatement evaluation found primary clarifier covers and gas scrubbers very expensive to build and maintain and potentially hazardous to staff, and a pilot showed dissolved oxygen could remove the H₂S before the headworks. (PDF page 1) (opens in a new tab)
How is this installation different from a force main system?
Most ECO₂ systems prevent sulfide from forming; here the wastewater already carries 3 to 6 mg/L of dissolved sulfide, and the added oxygen oxidizes it within minutes before it escapes as H₂S. (PDF page 2) (opens in a new tab)
How big is the system?
Two 12 ft diameter, 20 ft high cones in a 30 ft deep vault, each dissolving 6,900 lb/day of oxygen into a 9,875 gpm side stream from a 75 MGD, 72 inch force main. (PDF page 2) (opens in a new tab)
The Project

TRA Central Plant Influent Pump Station
In Full
More Key Figures
Two more, each with what it measures and its PDF page.
From the PDF
| Figure | What It Measures |
|---|---|
| 70 hp | Pump feeding each cone's side stream (PDF page 2 (opens in a new tab)) |
| 12 ft | Cone diameter (20 ft high), two cones in a 30 ft deep vault (PDF page 2 (opens in a new tab)) |
Full Text as Published
The text as its authors wrote it.
Trinity River Authority of Texas, Dallas, TX
Central Regional Wastewater System
Total Treated Flow of 150 MGD
Reference: Betty Jordan, PE, Alan Plummer Associates, Inc.
Project Description
The Trinity River Authority (TRA) of Texas provides water and wastewater treatment, water supply and reservoir systems to a population of over 3.5 million, including the Dallas, Fort Worth area. Since the early 1970's, the Authority has included odor control as one of the top priorities in its master plan, and in 2003, the TRA completed a comprehensive odor abatement evaluation. After evaluation of structural and chemical odor control options, TRA selected the ECO₂ SuperOxygenation System as part of their Stage VII Odor Control Improvement Program.
One of the goals of the odor abatement program is to reduce odorous emissions in the primary clarifiers. Structural options including primary clarifier covers and gas scrubbers were very expensive to construct and maintain and were potentially hazardous to employees. A pilot study using dissolved oxygen showed that the highly odorous and hazardous hydrogen sulfide could be effectively removed prior to wastewater reaching the treatment plant headworks.
Two ECO₂ SuperOxygenation Cones dissolve a total of 13,800 lbs of pure oxygen into a wastewater sidestream to elevate the D.O. in the 150MGD influent to a minimum of 11 mg/l D.O. at the headworks.
Primary Clarifier Odor Control
Trinity River Authority (TRA) of Texas
The Trinity River Authority's Central Regional Wastewater System, located in Dallas, Texas, serves over 3 million people in 20 north Texas cities, including the Dallas / Fort Worth area. TRA's main treatment facility is the Central Regional Wastewater System, which includes a 200 mile collection system. The CRWS is an award-winning treatment facility, known for its innovative programs and operations excellence.
The ECO₂ SuperOxygenation System, designed in conjunction with consulting engineers, Alan Plummer Associates is in operation at TRA's Central Regional Wastewater System treatment plant, oxygenating influent into the primary clarifiers in order to oxidize any existing sulfides before they can escape to the atmosphere as H₂S. The ECO₂ System is meeting all of the performance objectives.
ECO₂ SuperOxygenation System at TRA's Influent Pump Station
Schematic of the ECO₂ SuperOxygenation System at the TRA Influent Pump Station: two existing force mains of 75 MGD each run to the headworks; a 70 Hp pump (9,875 gpm each) draws raw wastewater to each ECO₂ cone (20 ft high, 12 ft wide), supplied with 6,900 lbs/day of oxygen each, discharging at D.O. 60 mg/L, in a 30 ft x 30 ft x 30 ft concrete vault.
Two 12 ft. dia. ECO₂ Cones have been installed in a 30 ft. deep vault adjacent to the TRA influent pump station.
Project Objectives
Traditionally, ECO₂ SuperOxygenation Systems have been used to prevent anaerobic conditions in force mains, preventing sulfide formation. The TRA Installation is different as it adds dissolved oxygen to water from the collection system, that is already contaminated with dissolved sulfides (3-6mg/L). The added D.O. oxidizes the existing sulfides within a few minutes before they can escape as H₂S in the influent channels.
Project objectives for the installation at TRA included:
- Dissolve >90% of supplied oxygen into wastewater
- Provide a minimum DO of 60 mg/l at discharge point of SuperOxygenation system
- Provide a final minimum DO of 11 mg/l in the stream at the entrance to the treatment plant
Project Results
The ECO₂ SuperOxygenation System has been in operation since 2006 and meets all of the design criteria.
Technical Specifications
| Influent Lines (2 each) | |
|---|---|
| Flow, average | 75 MGD |
| Length of force main | 1,250 ft. |
| Diameter of force main | 72 in. |
| Pressure at system connection | 19 psig |
| Retention time at average flow | 11 min. |
| ECO₂ System Design (2 each) | |
|---|---|
| Cone diameter | 12 ft. |
| Cone height | 20 ft. |
| Oxygen dissolution rate | 6,900 lb./day |
| Sidestream flow | 9,875 gpm |
| Sidestream D.O. | 60 mg/l |
The ECO₂ SuperOxygenation Technology is an innovative, economical and environmentally friendly odor control solution for municipal wastewater systems including Force Mains, Headworks and Primary Clarifiers. The ECO₂ System dissolves oxygen into wastewater at an oxygen transfer rate of well over 90%. Dissolved oxygen readily reacts with existing sulfides and prevents anaerobic conditions and the formation of sulfides in wastewater. Eliminating hydrogen sulfide (H₂S) not only prevents odor, but also costly corrosion of pipes and treatment plant equipment.
How to Cite
One line to paste into a report.
TRA Primary Clarifier Superoxygenation System for Odor and Corrosion Control. ECO₂. Project engineer: Alan Plummer & Associates. Eco Oxygen Technologies Technical Library. https://eco2tech.com/technical-library/tra-primary-clarifier-superoxygenation-system-for-odor-and-corrosion-control/
https://eco2tech.com/technical-library/tra-primary-clarifier-superoxygenation-system-for-odor-and-corrosion-control/
The Next Step
Ask an ECO₂ Engineer
Questions about this case study, or about your own water? An application engineer answers, with the figures.
