Super-oxygenation as a solution to wastewater system corrosion and for odour control
A 2010 article making the case for preventing hydrogen sulfide in sewers and plants with dissolved pure oxygen, rather than treating it after it forms.
Details
Summary
Prevent H₂S, Don't Treat It
Sewer odor and corrosion start when wastewater uses up its little dissolved oxygen and bacteria make hydrogen sulfide. This May 2010 article argues for preventing H₂S rather than treating it, by dissolving pure oxygen into force mains, gravity sewers, plant influent and primary clarifiers. In Regina, Saskatchewan, one system adds 280 pounds of oxygen a day (pp. 1, 2).
Key Figures
280lbs/day
Pure oxygen added to the Harbour Landing force main in Regina Source: PDF page 2 (opens in a new tab)
2,500homesites
Single family homesites in the Harbour Landing development, plus 1,500 townhomes Source: PDF page 2 (opens in a new tab)
15 to 30minutes
Travel time upstream of the headworks at which to oxygenate influent (at least) Source: PDF page 3 (opens in a new tab)
Questions
Why does wastewater produce hydrogen sulfide?
Organic wastewater quickly uses up its limited dissolved oxygen. With no oxygen or nitrate left, bacteria produce H₂S along with indoles, skatoles and mercaptans (p. 1).
How does H₂S corrode concrete sewers?
Where bacteria in the headspace can reach air, they turn H₂S into sulfuric acid, which corrodes concrete and steel downstream of where the sulfide formed (p. 1).
How far upstream of a treatment plant should oxygen be added?
At least 15 to 30 minutes of travel time before the plant. That allows complete biological oxidation of the existing H₂S before the flow reaches the headworks, and prevents more from forming (p. 3).
How much dissolved oxygen does a primary clarifier need to stop odor?
The article gives 20 to 30 mg/L, enough to keep the clarifier oxic and stop H₂S forming in the bulk water (p. 3).
Why are deep, slow gravity sewers short of oxygen?
Gas exchange across the water surface depends on velocity and depth. In deep, low-velocity sewers it is low, so little oxygen is absorbed from the air above (p. 2).
Why do sewers produce odor and corrosion?
Wastewater quickly uses up its limited dissolved oxygen; with no oxygen or nitrate, bacteria make hydrogen sulfide, which turns to sulfuric acid in the headspace and corrodes concrete and steel. (PDF page 1) (opens in a new tab)
What is the alternative to treating odors after they form?
Preventing them by keeping the wastewater aerobic, for example by dissolving pure oxygen into a side stream returned to the force main. (PDF page 2) (opens in a new tab)
What was installed in Regina?
An ECO₂ system adding 280 pounds of pure oxygen a day to the force main serving the Harbour Landing development. (PDF page 2) (opens in a new tab)
How much oxygen does a primary clarifier need?
Providing 20 to 30 mg/L of dissolved oxygen keeps the clarifier oxic and stops hydrogen sulfide forming in the bulk water. (PDF page 3) (opens in a new tab)
In Full
More Key Figures
Five more, each with what it measures and its PDF page.
From the PDF
| Figure | What It Measures |
|---|---|
| 20 to 30 mg/L | Dissolved oxygen that keeps a primary clarifier oxic (PDF page 3 (opens in a new tab)) |
| 280 lbs/day | Pure oxygen the Harbour Landing system in Regina was designed to add (PDF page 2 (opens in a new tab)) |
| 2,500 homesites | Single family homesites in the Harbour Landing development, with 1,500 townhome sites (PDF page 2 (opens in a new tab)) |
| At least 15 to 30 minutes | Travel time before the plant at which to oxygenate the influent sewer (PDF page 3 (opens in a new tab)) |
| 50 or more years | Service life municipalities expect from their wastewater infrastructure (PDF page 4 (opens in a new tab)) |
The Full Write-Up
The problem, the work, the results and who did it.
Odor & Corrosion Begin with Oxygen's Low Solubility
Kevin Jacobs traces both problems to one cause: oxygen dissolves poorly in water. Wastewater full of organic matter quickly uses up what little dissolved oxygen it carries, and conditions turn anaerobic (p. 1).
With no dissolved oxygen and no nitrate left, bacteria produce indoles, skatoles, mercaptans and, above all, hydrogen sulfide. These compounds are volatile and offensive even at very low concentrations. Warm weather makes it worse, because bacteria grow more active while oxygen becomes less soluble (p. 1).
Corrosion follows the odor. Where bacteria in the headspace can reach air, they oxidize H₂S to sulfuric acid, which attacks concrete and steel. Most sewers are buried, so the damage is hard to watch, and often the first sign is a collapsed sewer and an unbudgeted repair bill (pp. 1, 2). Municipalities that expect their sewers to last 50 or more years are seeing them fail much sooner (p. 4).
Prevent the Sulfide Instead of Treating the Smell
The article sets out two approaches. The common one lets odorous compounds form and then treats them, with costly and potentially hazardous chemicals or by covering headspaces and scrubbing the foul air. Jacobs notes that this does nothing about the corrosive by-products. The other approach stops H₂S forming at all, and he calls the efficient addition of pure oxygen the simplest and most effective way to do it (p. 2).
In a force main the problem grows with high microbial oxygen uptake, long retention times and low dissolved oxygen. ECO₂'s Superoxygenation system dissolves pure oxygen into a side stream of wastewater and blends it back into the force main, keeping the whole main aerobic. Any H₂S formed upstream is consumed by bacteria in the aerobic zone (p. 2).
The article's example is Harbour Landing in Regina, Saskatchewan, a development of 2,500 single family homesites and 1,500 townhome sites that needed its own sewage lift station. Planners chose a Superoxygenation system designed to add 280 pounds of pure oxygen a day. Jacobs expects it to keep working as the development grows, with no increase in operating costs (p. 2).
The Same Idea for Gravity Sewers, Headworks & Primary Clarifiers
Jacobs extends the method beyond force mains. Gas exchange at a sewer's surface depends on the water's velocity and depth, so deep, slow gravity interceptors take up little oxygen from the air above them. They too suit added oxygen, and the economics of pure oxygen compare well with chemical oxidants (p. 2).
At a treatment plant, he recommends oxygenating the influent sewer at a point at least 15 to 30 minutes of travel time before the plant (pp. 2, 3). Bacteria then oxidize the sulfide already present, and no more forms before the flow reaches the bar screens, where turbulence would strip H₂S into the air (p. 3).
Primary clarifiers are often a plant's main odor source, with high BOD, long detention and a quiet surface that takes up little oxygen. The answer is to raise influent dissolved oxygen above what the clarifier consumes. Providing 20 to 30 mg/L keeps the clarifier oxic and stops H₂S forming in the bulk water, while bacteria oxidize the sulfide rising from the sludge layer (pp. 3, 4). The aeration tank then uses less oxygen, in proportion to what the clarifier consumed, so odor is prevented with no net increase in oxygen demand and no tank covers (p. 4).
Written by Kevin Jacobs of Eco Oxygen Technologies
Kevin Jacobs of Eco Oxygen Technologies wrote the article for the May 2010 issue of Environmental Science & Engineering Magazine (pp. 1, 4). It names the City of Regina as the owner of the Harbour Landing project and says its planners chose oxygen, but it names no design engineer.
What It Means If You Are Paying to Treat Odor After It Forms
If your odor program relies on chemicals, covers or scrubbers, this article makes the case for moving upstream. Treating the air removes the smell, but the sulfide behind the corrosion stays in the water. Keeping the wastewater aerobic removes the cause (p. 2).
It also gives two design rules worth checking on your own system: add oxygen at least 15 to 30 minutes of travel time ahead of the headworks, and provide 20 to 30 mg/L in a primary clarifier (p. 3). Jacobs adds that the low cost of pure oxygen gives it a substantial advantage over other oxidizing chemicals (p. 4).
Written up from the published article. Every figure is as the published article prints it, with the PDF page it comes from; the authors' own words appear only in quotation marks.
How to Cite
One line to paste into a report.
Kevin Jacobs. Super-oxygenation as a solution to wastewater system corrosion and for odour control. Environmental Science & Engineering Magazine, May 2010. Eco Oxygen Technologies Technical Library. https://eco2tech.com/technical-library/super-oxygenation-as-a-solution-to-wastewater-system-corrosion-and-for-odour-control/
https://eco2tech.com/technical-library/super-oxygenation-as-a-solution-to-wastewater-system-corrosion-and-for-odour-control/
The Next Step
Ask an ECO₂ Engineer
Questions about this published article, or about your own water? An application engineer answers, with the figures.
