Selection and Optimization of Liquid-Phase Odor Control Technologies
Two odor control engineers sort the sulfide treatments for sewers into preventers and reactors, give practice doses, and show a simple way to size oxygen for a force main.
Details
Summary
Choosing a Liquid-Phase Odor Control
This WEF webcast shows how engineers choose among the chemicals and oxygen that control sulfide in sewers. Dick Pope of Hazen and Sawyer and Bruce Koetter of Webster Environmental Associates sort them into preventers and reactors, give practice doses for each, and set out a simple way to size oxygen injection for a force main (pp. 3, 6, 39, 46, 47).
Key Figures
0.5mg/L D.O.
Dissolved oxygen below which a gravity sewer turns septic Source: PDF page 7 (opens in a new tab)
7.2kg NO₃-O per kg sulfide
Nitrate dose to prevent sulfide forming Source: PDF page 21 (opens in a new tab)
3.5kg Fe per kg sulfide
Optimal iron salt dose in practice Source: PDF page 27 (opens in a new tab)
Questions
What is the difference between preventing and treating sewer sulfide?
Preventers such as oxygen, nitrate and caustic scour stop sulfide forming. Reactors bind it, oxidize it or shift the pH once it has formed (pp. 5, 6).
How much oxygen does a force main need to stop sulfide?
The oxygen uptake rate times the retention time, plus about 2 mg/L per mg/L of sulfide already present, plus the residual wanted at the discharge. The webcast's example needs 111 mg/L (pp. 46, 47).
How much oxygen can be dissolved in a force main?
Koetter's rule of thumb is 1 mg/L per foot of pressure, so 115 ft (50 psi) at the pump discharge gives 115 mg/L. If the demand is higher, two systems in series may be needed (p. 47).
Does pH affect sewer odor?
Yes. Only the H₂S form of sulfide can strip out of solution; the ionic forms stay dissolved, and sulfide is more soluble in alkaline conditions. pH maintenance holds wastewater at pH 8.0 to 9.5 (pp. 11, 40).
Where does sewer sulfide come from?
Sulfate reducing bacteria in the slime layer on the pipe wall convert sulfate to sulfide when no oxygen is available; force mains, with a full slime layer and no air space, are especially prone. (PDF page 7) (opens in a new tab)
Why does pH matter for odor?
Only the H₂S form can strip out of solution and cause odor and corrosion; the HS- and S= forms stay dissolved, and sulfide is more soluble in alkaline conditions. (PDF page 11) (opens in a new tab)
What is the difference between preventers and reactors?
Preventers such as oxygen, nitrate and caustic scour stop sulfide forming; reactors bind it (iron salts, polymeric amine), oxidize it (chlorine, peroxide, permanganate) or shift pH. (PDF page 6) (opens in a new tab)
How is the oxygen needed for a force main estimated?
Oxygen uptake rate times retention time, plus about 2 mg/L per mg/L of dissolved sulfide already present, plus the residual D.O. wanted at the discharge; the example totals 111 mg/L. (PDF page 47) (opens in a new tab)
How do you know if the oxygen will dissolve?
Compare the demand with the saturation capacity, roughly 1 mg/L per foot of pressure; at 115 ft (50 psi) about 115 mg/L. If demand is higher, it is a poor fit or needs two systems in series. (PDF page 47) (opens in a new tab)
In Full
More Key Figures
11 more, each with what it measures and its PDF page.
From the PDF
| Figure | What It Measures |
|---|---|
| 5 to 15 kg chlorine per kg sulfide | Hypochlorite dose in practice (PDF page 32 (opens in a new tab)) |
| 5 to 10 mg/L/hr | Common oxygen uptake rate for wastewater (PDF page 46 (opens in a new tab)) |
| 2 mg/L O₂ per 1 mg/L sulfide | Extra oxygen to oxidize dissolved sulfide already present (PDF page 47 (opens in a new tab)) |
| 1 mg/L O₂ per ft of pressure | Rule of thumb for how much oxygen the water can hold (PDF page 47 (opens in a new tab)) |
| 0.5 mg/L | Dissolved oxygen below which a gravity sewer turns septic (PDF page 7 (opens in a new tab)) |
| 5 to 10 mg/L per hour | Common oxygen uptake rate for wastewater (PDF page 46 (opens in a new tab)) |
| 2 mg/L O₂ per 1 mg/L sulfide | Extra oxygen to oxidize sulfide already present (rule of thumb) (PDF page 47 (opens in a new tab)) |
| 111 mg/L | Total oxygen required in the worked force main example (PDF page 47 (opens in a new tab)) |
| 1 mg/L O₂ per ft of pressure | How much oxygen the water can hold (rule of thumb) (PDF page 47 (opens in a new tab)) |
| 7.2 kg nitrate oxygen per kg sulfide | Nitrate dose to prevent sulfide forming (PDF page 21 (opens in a new tab)) |
| 3 to 7 days | How long a caustic shock dose inactivates sulfate reducing bacteria (PDF page 40 (opens in a new tab)) |
The Full Write-Up
The problem, the work, the results and who did it.
Sulfide Forms in the Slime Layer Once Oxygen Runs Out
Liquid-phase odor control is first and foremost about wastewater sulfide: reduce it, and odor, health and safety risk and corrosion all fall (p. 4). Sulfide forms in the slime layer, about 1 mm thick, on a pipe's wetted wall. In a gravity sewer, wastewater is aerobic above 0.5 mg/L of dissolved oxygen and septic below it (pp. 7, 8). A force main is worse: slime covers its full circumference and there is no air space to supply oxygen. Surcharged lines and inverted siphons behave the same way (p. 7).
Short of oxygen, sulfate reducing bacteria take it from the sulfate already in the wastewater and make sulfide (p. 9). Only the H₂S form can strip out of solution and cause odor and corrosion; the two ionic forms stay dissolved. Which form dominates depends on pH, and sulfide is more soluble in alkaline conditions (pp. 10, 11). Warm wastewater, low dissolved oxygen, plenty of soluble BOD, long detention times and deposits all make it worse (p. 12).
Know the System, Then Choose a Preventer or a Reactor
Pope starts with the system: drawings, complaints, earlier studies, the hydraulic model and the staff, then field data on H₂S and pressure in the air and sulfide, BOD, temperature, pH and dissolved oxygen in the wastewater (p. 13). Sewer sulfide models find hot spots and simulate chemical addition, and jar tests show which chemicals work and at what dose (p. 14). Doses are almost never stoichiometric, and reaction time matters (p. 15).
The treatments fall into two groups. Preventers keep sulfide from forming: air or oxygen, nitrates and caustic scour. Reactors deal with it once formed: binders such as iron salts, oxidizers such as chlorine, hydrogen peroxide and permanganate, and pH adjusters such as caustic, magnesium hydroxide and lime (p. 6).
Practice doses differ widely. Nitrate takes 7.2 kg of nitrate oxygen per kg of sulfide prevented, iron salts about 3.5 kg of iron per kg of sulfide, hypochlorite 5 to 15 kg of chlorine per kg of sulfide, and hydrogen peroxide 2 to 4 parts per part of sulfide (pp. 21, 27, 32, 36). Caustic shock dosing raises pH to 12.5 to 13 for 30 minutes and inactivates the sulfate reducing bacteria for 3 to 7 days (p. 40).
Oxygen Sized from the Uptake Rate & the Travel Time
Koetter sizes oxygen injection for a force main in two steps. The demand is the oxygen uptake rate (OUR) times the hydraulic retention time. An OUR of 5 to 10 mg/L per hour is common, so 10 mg/L per hour over 10 hours needs 100 mg/L (p. 46). Sulfide already in the flow adds about 2 mg/L of oxygen per 1 mg/L, and it oxidizes 5 to 20 minutes after oxic conditions return. With 6 mg/L for existing sulfide and 5 mg/L of residual wanted at the discharge, the example totals 111 mg/L (p. 47).
Then check the water can hold it. His rule of thumb is 1 mg/L of oxygen per foot of pressure, so 115 ft (50 psi) at the pump discharge gives a saturation capacity of 115 mg/L. If the demand is lower, proceed; if higher, the application is poor or two systems in series may be needed (p. 47).
The design details follow: feed locations, liquid oxygen or on-site generation, side stream flow rate, and control by dissolved oxygen meters, raw sewage flow or the number of pumps running (pp. 48, 49). ECO₂ is among the oxygenation system manufacturers the slides list (p. 45).
Presented by Hazen and Sawyer and Webster Environmental, Co-Moderated by ECO₂
Richard J. (Dick) Pope, P.E., BCEE, is Vice President and Odor Services Leader at Hazen and Sawyer, with 37 years of odor assessment and control at more than 250 facilities and systems in 35 states and 10 countries (pp. 3, 38). Bruce Koetter, P.E., is President of Webster Environmental Associates, with 27 years of odor control experience (p. 39). ECO₂'s Eastern Regional Manager, Ali Trollier, co-moderated the webcast, held on April 30, 2020 (pp. 2, 3).
What It Means When You Choose a Treatment
The webcast's closing advice is that there are many liquid-phase options, and choosing well takes knowing your system's numbers, testing it, and knowing the alternatives and local preferences. Its selection list runs from control location, sulfide and H₂S levels and retention time to safety, corrosion control, effects on the treatment plant and cost (p. 50).
For oxygen, the two checks make a quick first screen with your own numbers: the uptake rate, the force main's retention time and the pressure at its pump discharge (pp. 46, 47).
Written up from the presentation. Every figure is as the presentation prints it, with the PDF page it comes from; the authors' own words appear only in quotation marks.
How to Cite
One line to paste into a report.
Richard J. Pope and Bruce Koetter. Selection and Optimization of Liquid-Phase Odor Control Technologies. WEF, April 2020. Project engineer: Hazen and Sawyer, Webster Environmental. Eco Oxygen Technologies Technical Library. https://eco2tech.com/technical-library/selection-and-optimization-of-liquid-phase-odor-control-technologies/
https://eco2tech.com/technical-library/selection-and-optimization-of-liquid-phase-odor-control-technologies/
The Next Step
Ask an ECO₂ Engineer
Questions about this presentation, or about your own water? An application engineer answers, with the figures.
