Laguna Beach, CA Stops Sewer Odor Complaints with Pure Oxygen
ECO₂'s case study of how Laguna Beach, California stopped sewer odor complaints by injecting pure oxygen at the Bluebird Lift Station instead of adding scrubbers.
Details
Summary
Laguna Beach had sewer odor complaints for years, and scrubbers would have tripled its chemical budget and left hazardous by-products. The city instead installed ECO₂ Superoxygenation with on-site oxygen generation, all inside the existing Bluebird Lift Station, in the Fall of 2006.
Key Figures
1.4MGD
Average flow at the Bluebird Lift Station Source: PDF page 1 (opens in a new tab)
5.4MGD
Maximum force main flow Source: PDF page 2 (opens in a new tab)
Questions
Why didn't Laguna Beach use scrubbers or chemicals?
Physical constraints and the high cost of chemicals made them impractical, and they produce hazardous waste by-products that need special handling and disposal. Vendor proposals showed scrubbers would triple the city's chemical budget and look unpleasant. (PDF page 2) (opens in a new tab)
How was the system made invisible?
On-site oxygen generation let the whole system, including the cone, oxygen generation, piping, pumps and controls, fit inside the existing Bluebird Lift Station. (PDF page 2) (opens in a new tab)
How quickly does the system pay back?
The city reports a return on investment of less than four years, with maintenance absorbed into the existing operations budget. (PDF page 2) (opens in a new tab)
How did Laguna Beach find Superoxygenation?
Staff surveyed nearby agencies and learned that Orange County Sanitation District had rigorously tested the technology and found it virtually eliminated hydrogen sulfide production. (PDF page 2) (opens in a new tab)
The Projects

SOCWA Lift Station

Bluebird Lift Station
In Full
More Key Figures
One more, each with what it measures and its PDF page.
From the PDF
| Figure | What It Measures |
|---|---|
| four years | Return on investment (less than) (PDF page 2 (opens in a new tab)) |
Full Text as Published
The text as its authors wrote it.
City of Laguna Beach, CA: Bluebird Lift Station
Force Main Odor and Corrosion Control, Onsite Oxygen Generation. Average Flow of 1.4 MGD.
Reference: Mr. David Shissler, Director of Water Quality, Laguna Beach, CA.
The City of Laguna Beach is a unique beach community with over seven miles of beautiful coastal beaches. The City has 24,000 residents and receives over 3 million visitors each year.
The City's pride in its beautiful canyons, coastal hills and beaches necessitated a nearly invisible, yet practical and cost-effective odor control solution for its sewer system.
The ECO₂ SuperOxygenation system combined with on-site oxygen generation guarantees an average of <5 ppm H2S levels, all within the footprint of the existing Bluebird Lift Station.
Project Description
Complaints of hydrogen sulfide odors from their sewer system led the California coastal community of Laguna Beach to investigate such odor control remedies as scrubbers, chemical treatment, pipeline enhancement and the new ECO₂ SuperOxygenation technology. Because of physical constraints and the high cost of chemicals, scrubbers and chemical treatment were not deemed practical or cost effective. In addition, hazardous waste by-products required special handling and expensive disposal.
The ECO₂ system offered several valuable advantages including a return on investment of less than four years, increased service life of the North Coast Interceptor pipeline (a result of preventing corrosion due to hydrogen sulfide formation) and the significant reduction of odors between the lift stations. The City elected to install on-site oxygen generation to allow the entire ECO₂ system to be built inside of the existing Bluebird Lift Station, providing an odor control system that is invisible to the surrounding beach community.
The ECO₂ system was designed specifically for Laguna Beach and guarantees an average H2S level of <5 ppm under design operating conditions. The 17,000 ft. force main handles a maximum flow of 5.4 MGD.
The ECO₂ SuperOxygenation system was installed during the Fall of 2006 and is meeting all design criteria.
Project History
The City of Laguna Beach received complaints of sewer system odors for many years, and in a 2003 engineering study, identified Hydrogen Sulfide as the primary source of the odors, with gas scrubbers as the recommended solution. After soliciting proposals from traditional vendors, the City concluded that scrubbers would triple their chemical budget, be aesthetically unpleasing and leave the City with hazardous waste by-products requiring special handling and disposal.
Staff surveyed nearby wastewater agencies and discovered that Orange County Sanitation District had rigorously tested a new technology—ECO₂ SuperOxygenation—that virtually eliminated the production of Hydrogen Sulfide. According to OCSD's project manager, the new system worked immediately and provided consistent performance.
With over seven miles of beautiful California beaches, Laguna Beach welcomes over 3 million visitors every year and its residents expect superior services and utility systems that blend in with the architecture and look of the community. Laguna Beach staff and ECO₂ engineers collaborated to design a nearly invisible odor control solution. The ECO₂ SuperOxygenation cone, oxygen generation system, and piping, pumps and controls all fit within the existing Bluebird Pump Station. The installation, start-up and testing were completed in the Fall of 2006.
The ECO₂ SuperOxygenation system has met Laguna Beach's expectations.
- Return on Investment of less than four years.
- An Invisible Installation, with all equipment fitting within the existing pump station.
- Minimal Maintenance that can be absorbed into the current operations budget.
- Increased Service Life of the North Coast Interceptor pipeline by reducing the development of corrosive acids in the system.
- Guaranteed Performance Levels, reducing H2S levels from over 300 ppm to <5 ppm. The measured performance of the system is ≤ 2 ppm.
The ECO₂ SuperOxygenation technology is an innovative, economical and environmentally friendly odor control solution for municipal wastewater systems including Force Main Odor Control, Headworks Odor Control, Primary Clarifier Odor Control and Dissolved Oxygen Discharge Compliance. ECO₂ technology was featured in the technical program during the 2006 Odor and Air Emissions specialty conference hosted by the Water Environment Federation and Air & Waste Management Association.
Technical Specifications
Force Main
- Flow, maximum: 5.4 MGD
- Flow, average: 1.4 MGD
- Length of force main: 16,896 ft.
- Diameter of force main: 24 to 30 in.
ECO₂ System
- Cone diameter: 4 ft.
- Cone height: 15 ft.
- Oxygen dissolution rate: 1,000 lb./day
- Sidestream flow: 1,000 gpm
- Measured performance, H2S: ≤ 2 ppm
- On-site Oxygen Generation
OdaLog showing H2S levels before and after start-up of ECO₂ SuperOxygenation System.
How to Cite
One line to paste into a report.
Laguna Beach, CA Stops Sewer Odor Complaints with Pure Oxygen. ECO₂, 2008. Eco Oxygen Technologies Technical Library. https://eco2tech.com/technical-library/laguna-beach-ca-stops-sewer-odor-complains-with-pure-oxygen/
https://eco2tech.com/technical-library/laguna-beach-ca-stops-sewer-odor-complains-with-pure-oxygen/
The Next Step
Ask an ECO₂ Engineer
Questions about this case study, or about your own water? An application engineer answers, with the figures.
