Odor Control Chemical Cost Comparison

ECO₂'s comparison of what liquid phase odor control costs, chemical by chemical and against dissolved oxygen, for controlling hydrogen sulfide in sewers.

Details

Publisher
ECO₂

Summary

ECO₂'s side-by-side comparison of six liquid phase methods of H₂S control: Superoxygenation with pure oxygen, chlorine, hydrogen peroxide, calcium nitrate (Bioxide), iron salts and magnesium hydroxide. For each it gives the lowest dissolved sulfide achievable, the dose, the product cost, storage and handling, and pros and cons.

Key Figures

Questions

What are the drawbacks of iron salts for sewer odor control?

They are hazardous and highly corrosive, need secondary containment and freeze protection, increase solids at the treatment plant, may reduce biosolids quality and can form deposits and iron film in pipes. (PDF page 2) (opens in a new tab)

Where is Superoxygenation effective for H₂S control?

For hotspots with more than 15 to 30 minutes of retention, force mains with less than 10 to 20 hours and gravity mains with less than 4 hours, and best on isolated lines without multiple flow inputs downstream. (PDF page 2) (opens in a new tab)

In Full

Full Text as Published

The text as its authors wrote it.
The technical paper's own words, as published. Its figures are the authors'; the PDF (2 pages) is the original, with the figures, photos and tables drawn as images.

Liquid phase sulfide control options: annual cost comparison

Chart in the PDF: annual cost (USD) of pure oxygen, chlorine, hydrogen peroxide, Bioxide, ferrous sulfate and magnesium hydroxide in three scenarios: Scenario A, a 1 MGD force main; Scenario B, a 6 MGD gravity main; Scenario C, a 10 MGD force main.

Liquid phase methods of H₂S control

ChemicalLowest H₂S achievableDose valuesProduct cost $/gal
SuperOxygenation (pure D.O.)DS~0 mg/L (H₂S~0 ppm)Dose O₂ = sum of (Removal = 2 lbs/lb DS) + (Prevent = OUR*HRT)$0.48
Chlorine (Clx)DS~0.5 mg/L (H₂S~20 ppm)Dose NaOCl = 5-15 lbs/lb DS$1.00
Hydrogen peroxide (H₂O₂)DS~0.1 mg/L (H₂S~5-10 ppm)Dose H₂O₂ = 1 gal/lb DS$3.00
Calcium nitrate ("Bioxide")DS~0.1 mg/L (H₂S~5-10 ppm)Dose NO₃ = 12 lbs/lb DS (Removal = 2-5 lbs/lb DS; Prevention = 7-10 lbs/lb DS)$2.50
Iron salts (Fex)DS~0.5 mg/L (H₂S~20 ppm)Dose FeSO₄ = 3.3 gal/lb of DS$1.30
Magnesium hydroxide ("ThioGuard")DS~0.5 mg/L (H₂S~20 ppm)Dose MgO = MGD * 70-140 mg/L$2.50
SuperOxygenation (pure D.O.)

High purity oxygen, oxygen injection.

  • Application: Requires equipment for dissolving oxygen to high concentration without entrained gas/bubbles. Effective in preventing DS formation by preventing anaerobic conditions. Effective for oxidizing DS, requires 15-30 minutes.
  • Storage and handling: Stored as liquid. Non-hazardous. Non-explosive. Tank owned by O₂ supplier.
  • Lowest H₂S achievable: DS~0 mg/L (H₂S~0 ppm)
  • Dose values: Dose O₂ = sum of (Removal = 2 lbs/lb DS) and (Prevent = OUR*HRT) [Ave. OUR = 10 ppm/hr] [Mult. by inefficiencies for oxygen gas purity and dissolution system]
  • Dose dependent on: Flow, HRT, OUR, and DS removed
  • Product cost: $0.48
  • Pros: Lowest operating cost. Effective for hotspots (HRT > 15-30 min). Effective for force mains (HRT < 10 - 20 hrs). Effective for gravity mains (HRT < 4 hrs). Able to eliminate H₂S & stop corrosion. No byproducts are produced. Optimal for isolated lines.
  • Cons: Requires sidestream equipment to dissolve gas. Limited use for long lines (high pressure allows long HRT). Not intended for lines with mult. flow inputs downstream.
Chlorine (Clx)

Hypochlorite/bleach (NaOCl), chlorine gas, chlorine tablets.

  • Application: Effective for rapid oxidation of DS.
  • Storage and handling: Hazardous. Highly corrosive. Requires secondary containment. May off-gas and degrade.
  • Lowest H₂S achievable: DS~0.5 mg/L (H₂S~20 ppm)
  • Dose values: Dose NaOCl = 5-15 lbs/lb DS
  • Dose dependent on: Flow and DS removed
  • Product cost: $1.00
  • Pros: Inexpensive and easy to access. Familiar to operators, easy feed.
  • Cons: May reduce active biomass feeding WWTP processes. Reacts with DS and other compounds. May increase corrosion if fed incorrectly.
Hydrogen peroxide (H₂O₂)
  • Application: Powerful oxidant, reacts quickly, but will not carry for long HRT. Can be effective for short force mains (<2 hrs HRT). Applicable for "hotspots", requires 15-20 minutes.
  • Storage and handling: Hazardous. Requires secondary containment. May require special training and security.
  • Lowest H₂S achievable: DS~0.1 mg/L (H₂S~5-10 ppm)
  • Dose values: Dose H₂O₂ = 1 gal/lb DS
  • Dose dependent on: Flow and DS removed and prevented
  • Product cost: $3.00
  • Pros: Rapid reaction. No byproducts are produced. Can be used to regenerate iron ("Pri-SC").
  • Cons: Reacts with DS and other compounds. May require multiple feed points precautions. May require special operators, training, and safety.
Calcium nitrate (CaNO₃) ("Bioxide")
  • Application: Requires 2-3 hrs min of contact time before effective. Can be used for long HRT. Can be dripped into wetwell. Can prevent sulfide formation downstream. Can oxidize existing sulfides.
  • Storage and handling: Non-hazardous.
  • Lowest H₂S achievable: DS~0.1 mg/L (H₂S~5-10 ppm)
  • Dose values: Dose NO₃ = 12 lbs/lb DS (Removal = 2-5 lbs/lb DS) (Prevention = 7-10 lbs/lb DS)
  • Dose dependent on: Flow and DS removed and prevented
  • Product cost: $2.50
  • Pros: Removes DS and prevents H₂S. Efficient in long gravity lines.
  • Cons: Best possible results yield DS = 0.5 mg/L (20 H₂S). May increase scum in wetwell. Increased nitrogen (as NO₃) to WWTP.
Iron salts (Fex)

Ferrous/ferric chloride / sulfate.

  • Application: Can be effective for long lines (gravity and force mains) to precipitate and remove sulfides.
  • Storage and handling: Hazardous. Highly corrosive. Requires secondary containment. Requires freeze protection.
  • Lowest H₂S achievable: DS~0.5 mg/L (H₂S~20 ppm)
  • Dose values: Dose FeSO₄ = 3.3 gal/lb of DS
  • Dose dependent on: Flow and DS removed
  • Product cost: $1.30
  • Pros: May help with settling and PO₄ at WWTP. Can be regenerated with H₂O₂ ("PRI-SC").
  • Cons: Increased solids production at WWTP. May reduce biosolids quality at WWTP. May form deposits in low velocity lines. May cause iron film on pipe walls and equipment.
Magnesium hydroxide (MgO) ("ThioGuard")
  • Application: Can be effective for high sulfide loading and low flows, both gravity and force mains. Elevates pH to keep sulfides from becoming H₂S.
  • Storage and handling: Non-hazardous slurry. Requires constant mixing. Requires freeze protection. Constant drip to avoid clogging feed lines.
  • Lowest H₂S achievable: DS~0.5 mg/L (H₂S~20 ppm)
  • Dose values: Dose MgO = MGD * 70-140 mg/L
  • Dose dependent on: Flow
  • Product cost: $2.50
  • Pros: Dose unaffected by sulfide levels. Inhibits biogrowth in pipe. May increase alkalinity to benefit WWTP.
  • Cons: Not cost-effective for low H₂S targets, or turbulent zones. Does not remove S, only prevents release as H₂S. H₂S may re-release if flow is mixed with low pH water. May deposit in feed-lines, wet-wells, & low-velocity lines.

How to Cite

One line to paste into a report.

Odor Control Chemical Cost Comparison. ECO₂. Eco Oxygen Technologies Technical Library. https://eco2tech.com/technical-library/odor-control-chemical-cost-comparison/

https://eco2tech.com/technical-library/odor-control-chemical-cost-comparison/

The Next Step

Ask an ECO₂ Engineer

Questions about this technical paper, or about your own water? An application engineer answers, with the figures.

A rebuilt sewage pump station with a planted roof beside Lake Sammamish