Gravity Sewer Odor and Corrosion Control
Why cooler sewers still corrode, and why controlling the corrosion, as Superoxygenation aims to do in large gravity mains, controls the odor at the same time.
Details
Summary
This ECO₂ application note explains why cooler climates do not escape sewer corrosion: concrete corrodes at near half its maximum rate whenever H₂S in the sewer air is between 2 and 55 ppm, regardless of temperature. Controlling corrosion, as Superoxygenation aims to do, controls odor at the same time.
Key Figures
2 to 55ppm
H₂S in sewer air at which sulfuric acid forms at near 50% of its maximum rate Source: PDF page 1 (opens in a new tab)
50%of maximum
H2SO4 generation rate across that H₂S range Source: PDF page 1 (opens in a new tab)
25ppm
H₂S in the sewer gas below which perceptible odors are much reduced Source: PDF page 1 (opens in a new tab)
Questions
Do sewers in cooler climates corrode less?
Not much. Cooler wastewater makes less H₂S, but sulfuric acid forms at near 50% of its maximum rate whenever H₂S in the sewer air is between 2 and 55 ppm, so the corrosion rate of concrete is not dependent on temperature. (PDF page 1) (opens in a new tab)
Is odor control the same as corrosion control?
No. Odors drop sharply once H₂S in the sewer gas is below 25 ppm, but concrete corrosion rates are only minimally reduced. If corrosion control is the goal, odor is controlled at the same time. (PDF page 1) (opens in a new tab)
In Full
Full Text as Published
The text as its authors wrote it.
Gravity Sewer Corrosion Control with SuperOxygenation
- Pure D.O. with No Bubbles
- Increase Remaining Useful Life
- Prevent Corrosion
- Maintain Aerobic Environment
The high BOD of domestic wastewater and limited reaeration rates commonly found in municipal gravity sewers enhance H2S production in the flowing wastewater during warm weather so that higher H2S concentrations in the air head space result. In cooler climates, the H2S concentration in the head space is considerably less than for warmer climates because the microbial generation of H2S proceeds more slowly at lower temperature. This has mistakenly led municipalities in cooler climates to assume that they will encounter fewer corrosion problems than their warmer climate colleagues. However, since H2SO4 generation rates are near 50% of maximum at H2S concentrations in the air above the flowing wastewater at 2-55 ppm, there is only a minor difference in corrosion rate with lower temperatures. Thus, the corrosion rate of the H2SO4 reaction with concrete is not dependent on temperature.
Therefore, even though perceptible odors are much reduced by H2S concentrations in the sewer gas phase below 25 ppm, concrete corrosion rates appear to be minimally reduced. This is particularly germane to cities in the colder climates where odor problems may be less severe than in warmer climates but where corrosion may be proceeding at nearly the same rates. These facts also have strong implications on the overall policy for H2S. Is the goal odor control or corrosion control? For instance, nitrate supplementation to gravity sewers cannot economically reduce dissolved H2S in the wastewater below about 0.5 mg/L, which can still result in over 25 ppm in the air space. This can markedly reduce odors but may result in little reduction of corrosion. Whereas, if corrosion control is the objective, there will be simultaneous control of odor.
Two to 55 ppm H2S has been the range of concentrations found to support 50% of the maximum potential rate of conversion to H2SO4.
SuperOxygenation Diagram.
How to Cite
One line to paste into a report.
Gravity Sewer Odor and Corrosion Control. ECO₂, 2020. Eco Oxygen Technologies Technical Library. https://eco2tech.com/technical-library/gravity-sewer-odor-and-corrosion-control/
https://eco2tech.com/technical-library/gravity-sewer-odor-and-corrosion-control/
The Next Step
Ask an ECO₂ Engineer
Questions about this application note, or about your own water? An application engineer answers, with the figures.
